• Email
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Pinterest
  • TikTok
  • Tumblr
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Tahlia Newland

Editor, Author & Artist

  • Editing Services
  • Me & My Creative Life
    • My Books
      • Metaphysical Fiction
    • My Poetry
    • My Masks
    • My Hats
    • Permaculture, Forest & Garden
    • Performing Arts
  • Blog
  • Contact

What’s in a star?

August 24, 2012 by Tahlia Newland

In the past, before ebooks and the rise of self-publishing as a viable option for serious authors, we could assume that although we didn’t necessarily like every book we read, we could assume that the writing was of a reasonable quality. If we wrote a review, all we had to do was say whether or not we liked the book. That’s easy. Now, however, especially if you’re reading ebooks, you can’t assume that quality, even from mainstream publishing houses. On the other hand, even at the cheap end of the market, you can’t assume poor quality, because there are plenty of books from self and Indie publishers that are every bit as good or better than anything published by the mainstream.

This gives reviews the vital function of being an arbiter of quality, not just an indication of how many people liked the book. However, we can’t assume that a review indicates the degree of quality of the writing because people use the star rating systems in different ways.

The personal opinion rating

  1. star – it was terrible
  2. stars – I didn’t like it
  3. stars – it was okay
  4. stars – I really liked it
  5. stars –  it was awesome/ exceptional

This tells us what the reviewer liked and what they didn’t. On this criteria you may hate what someone give 5 stars to and love what they give 1 star too. The quality of the book is not evaluated. This is how the Goodreads star system is explained.

The book quality rating.

  1. star – unacceptable standard/ a high degree of poor quality craftsmanship eg poor writing, bad or non-existent editing, one dimensional characters, poor plot, etc
  2. stars – has enough technical errors or poor crafting to be substandard.
  3. stars – crafted at an acceptable standard
  4. stars – crafted at a high standard
  5. stars – has that extra something.

This system is more likely to be used by other writers and will have some affect on most ‘professional’ reviewers.

The to-buy or not-to-buy rating

  1. star – Don’t buy it
  2. stars – I don’t recommend it
  3. stars – It’s worth buying if you like that kind of thing
  4. stars – It’s a really good read. I recommend it.
  5. stars –  you really should read this one.

This message is inherent in any rating system.

The combined rating

  1. star – unacceptable craftsmanship. It will include some, but not necessarily all, of the following; unacceptable number of copy- editing errors, poor plot, shallow characters, info dumps, structural defects, clumsy expression, grammatical errors etc. It should never have been published in this state. Don’t buy it.
  2. stars – substandard craftsmanship. The faults may be simply less in number than those in the first category, or they may be more subtle in nature. They will have more than one of the following: all expositional or passive writing (eg over-use of variations of the ‘to be’ verb), major point of view (P.O.V) confusion (eg poorly executed head-hopping), major plot holes, limited character development or is a rip-off of another book. They may have clean copy or too many copy-editing mistakes.
  3. stars – worth buying. A three star book will have no major structural defects. Either I didn’t enjoy it enough to give it 4 stars, or the writing needs some minor improvement but the story has sufficient good qualities for them not to be a major issue. For example it may, or may not, have P.O.V problems, mild plot holes or passive writing. Others may well enjoy it. Buy it if you like the sound of it and the things I didn’t like aren’t an issue for you.
  4. stars – a well-crafted book that I liked, or an exceptionally well crafted book that didn’t inspire me enough to add one more star.
  5.  stars – an exceptionally well crafted book that I liked, or a well crafted book that had that extra spark that really excites me.

The combined rating is the criteria I use. In this system, personal taste only comes into play from 3 stars and upwards. I feel that this is the fairest way to use the star rating, so that a book that is well enough written doesn’t drop in ratings just because I personally didn’t like it.

The poll on whether authors should publish reviews of less than 3 stars was overwhelmingly in favour of publishing such reviews (when I last checked). The reason being that without such informed reviews, the reading public isn’t getting the information they need to make the decision of whether to purchase or not. Luckily, I am seeing less books in the 1 and 2 star criteria these days, because from now on, in fairness to readers, I will be leaving reviews for them on Amazon and Goodreads. I won’t put them here though, because I figure you really don’t want to hear about them.

What criteria do you use to rate books in 5 stars?

 

Share this:

  • Click to share on Twitter (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on LinkedIn (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window)
  • Click to share on Tumblr (Opens in new window)
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window)

Related

Filed Under: Book talk Tagged With: book reviews, rating criteria, star ratings, writing reviews

« Review: H2O the Novel by Austin Boyd and Brannon Hollingsworth
Review: Quest for Celestia by Steven James »

Comments

  1. richardbunning says

    August 24, 2012 at 3:57 pm

    You have described the thinking we all should try to mirror, making the best of a loose and brutally crude system.
    Don’t forget to check reviewers other reviews, and if they are other authors to check for whom they have cross reviewed. Note that there are far more positives than negatives in most peer reviewing, although we can’t deny the terrible exceptions.
    Or else, just go with your gut feelings and a comfortable for you price making a gamble worthwhile.
    Perhaps Amazon should post on-site a version of your policy, Tahlia.

    • Tahlia Newland says

      August 26, 2012 at 11:11 am

      Thanks Richard.

  2. Diane says

    August 24, 2012 at 7:06 pm

    I generally use the combined evaluation system but leave myself wiggle room, for example recently I read a book by a very well known author, it reached his normal good standard except for one huge plot hole. This mistake spoilt my enjoyment of the book but didn’t negate all the other good points which I had come to expect from him. I reduced his star rating by one on that occasion and emailed him. I had a very nice response with both an explanation and an apology for the fact that the error had crept in and a reassurance that they were in the middle of correcting it. If a book is really poorly edited – by that I mean such bad grammar that it ends up that is all I can see, or the writing is simply poor (and there are some out there I believe) then I can’t finish it and I have to, in all conscience give it low star ratings. Mind you I have to admit that in those cases I am more likely to send them back and I think that conveys the message quite strongly.

    Great post – thanks – Diane

    • Tahlia Newland says

      August 26, 2012 at 11:19 am

      One of the things that came out clearly in the poll http://tahlianewland.com/2012/08/13/should-authors-publish-negative-book-reviews/ was that the 40% of people that said ‘sometimes’ indicate that we need to take various things into account when deciding whether to post a negative review. I found a book with one review (5 stars) and I wanted to give it a 2 star review for the sake of the readers who really shouldn’t be being asked to part with money for a book of that standard, but since the author only had one review, I didn’t post it. If that book had several 5 star reviews, I would have posted the low star review to balance out the others.

Search

Recent Posts

  • Fantasy Book Review: The High Priestess by Val Tobin
  • Book Genres – What you Need to Know.
  • How to See Edits in Word Documents
  • Finding an Editor You Can Trust
  • Review of ‘The Guild Codex Spellbound Series’ by Annette Marie

View Posts by Category

Writing a novel? Feeling overwhelmed? Get new insight and inspiration with my FREE Novel Revision Checklist. 

DOWNLOAD  NOW

Subscribe to Blog via Email

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Free Book Download  
Get Lethal Inheritance free when you sign up to my new release email list.  I won’t share your details and you can unsubscribe at any time.

My Latest Books

  • Fallout: Recovering from Abuse in Tibetan Buddhism
  • The Elements of Active Prose: Writing Tips to Make Your Prose Shine
  • The Locksmith's Secret
    Rated 5.00 out of 5

Alliance of Independent Authors

Alliance of Independent Authors

Click HERE to see all my books.

Books
Reviews, Writing, Cats & Contemplation
Editing

Click HERE to subscribe to my newsletter and get my fantasy novel Lethal Inheritance FREE. 

How to Meditate – the crucial points

See more

Hi I’m Tahlia Newland

I can help you express yourself and share your story with the world.

 

Do you want to write a really good story and have it professionally polished and published?

As an editor, I help you be the best writer you can possibly be. I strengthen your voice, support your vision and can assist you all the way to publication.

On my blog you’ll find book reviews, writer’s tips, contemplative articles on meditation and working with your mind, and occaisonally pictures of my Burmese cats.

If you’re interested mostly in my contemplative articles then  Sign up to the Living in Peace & Clarity Newsletter to get those articles delivered by email. And check out the resources on my Living in Peace and Clarity Page.

I do a lot of community work involving blogging and general support for Buddhist students processing revelations of abuse in their spiritual communities.  Please consider supporting me to continue this work.

Occiasonally, when inspired and not too busy with community work, I make masks.

All my books are

Visit my Mask & Steampunk Accessories Shop

2015-03-19 15.46.12
Blue Burmese
Like cats in stories? Check out my books. And click the photo to read the cat colomn.

Click Here for More Articles in This Series

Book reviews – sci fi, fantasy, literary fiction, Buddhist fiction and related non-fiction

Fantasy Book Review: The High Priestess by Val Tobin

Fantasy Book Review: The High Priestess by Val Tobin

The High Priestess: Persephone’s Return is the third book in Val Tobin’s Tales from the Unmasqued World Series, and in it she deepens and expands the stories from the previous two book. The book has two central story arcs based around characters we’ve met before. One arc follows Kelsey (a human) who is with Josh […]

More Posts from this Category

My gorgeous Burmese cats

Renovated Website & Cute Cat Series

Renovated Website & Cute Cat Series

Yesterday I did a photoshoot for my renovated website. Take a look around, particulary at the home page (Click on my name at the top to go there). It’s designed for editing clients with my books secondary because I need to focus on the part of this publishing business that actually earns me more than […]

More Posts from this Category

Seven of my novels have an Awesome Indies Seal of Excellence

Four of my books earned BRAG Medallions

I abide by the ethical author code

I'm an Ethical Author
Alliance of Independent Authors

Copyright

All material on this website is under copyright to Tahlia Newland and cannot be shared without written permission.

  • Editing Services
  • About Me
  • My Books
  • My Masks
  • Blog
  • Contact

Copyright © 2023 · Amoré Theme by Oh, Hello Designs on Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

FREE Novel Revision Checklist

Written a book? Need some help reviewing and revising it? Download my Novel Revision Checklist for step by step guidance.  

DOWNLOAD NOW

no thanks

{"cookieName":"wBounce","isAggressive":false,"isSitewide":true,"hesitation":"120","openAnimation":false,"exitAnimation":false,"timer":"","sensitivity":"","cookieExpire":"7","cookieDomain":"","autoFire":"","isAnalyticsEnabled":false}

Please note: I am closed for holidays from Christmas day until Jan 30th 2023. Dismiss